Breaking dawn is the last book in the Twilight Series by Stephanie Meyer. The book is divided into three "books" told from the perspective of both Bella Sawn and Jacob Black. This much anticipated novel was released on August 2, 2008.Catherine's Review
I gave this book a C. You may be asking me why I read it then? Any person who loved books 1-3 could not NOT read this book. We've been waiting for it since we read the last page of Eclipse. I was very glad that I read it because if I hadn't, I would have always wondered.
So what's wrong with it? I had several personal issues with the book and the story line.
- I think the entire wolf imprinting on a new born baby thing has always been a bit...wrong. Maybe this is because as a child I had a very creepy adult stalker who liked to talk to me in the halls and see how I was doing and would bring me presents and call me on the phone. I know Jacob is only worried about her best interests, and I don't understand because I'm not a wolf, but any adult evening thinking about "ending up" with any child is wrong. Also, Jacob's imprinting on Nessie seems to be taking away from Nessie's agency to choose her own future. Fair? I think not.
- Why doesn't Stephanie Meyer get Jacob out of the way and let Edward be the father he's supposed to be? I didn't like that Jacob's relationship with Nessie totally took away from and overshadowed Edward's relationship with his daughter. Move over Jacob and let Edward take care of his family!
- I got no sense of a true mother-daughter bond between Nessie and Bella. When is Bella going to cut it out and become a mother? I felt like her first interaction with Nessie was so non nonchalant. Also, when Alex was born I specifically remember Patricia and Patrick having a few moments (about an hour) just to be together and take in the moment. Now I know at initial birth, Bella was in no condition for this, but at first meeting Nesse, shoulnd't there have been that tender moment? Now, stephanie meyer is a mother of four (?) - so you'd think she'd at least get THIS right.
- What kind of a name is Reneseme? This went a bit too far for me. It was just dumb.
- Where's the battle? There were no real and final challenges for the main characters. Bella's wedding was perfect. They fought no war. Bella had minimal pain and suffering in her transformation. Bella was never really a new-born. Bella's daughter is easy to raise because she's basically being raised by Nannies. The other Twilight books were so good because they climaxed towards this HUGE challenge (whatever it was for that particular book) and then the characters banded together and overcame. Yeah, there were scares here and there and a bit of a confrontation at the end, but where's the big challenge to overcome? I think a review by Publisher's Weekly got it right - everyone got they're own way. It was a perfect fairy tail ending. I wish that they would have fought (and won) for what they believed in, not just settled things and walked away. Wouldn't one crazy last battle make a great movie too? I'm just trying to help here...
- Stop the mumbo jumbo. There are so many extra paragraphs that could have been cut out of this book. I found myself skipping paragraphs that just wasted my time. Why not just start the book out where "Book 3" started and focus on making THAT storyline so great? We all could have filled in the blanks with anything that happened in Book 2 and 1.
- Who cares about Jacob.
- My biggest complaint about the book? It left no room for my imagination to fill in the blanks. The series should have stopped at three. Eclipse let our imaginations run wild. That's where the story should have stopped. Any questions I ever had, any perfect ending I would ever want, any future that my own mind would have resolved, any creative liberty my own desires would have taken with the story - my right to these were all taken away. Stephanie gives it all away. This totally took the fun and the mystery and excitement out of the entire series. I wanted my own ending for Bella and Edward. I am sure people who actually liked Jacob felt the same way about his side of the story. Also, too many sex details - that would have been much better left alone for people to fill in the blanks themselves. There was no need for more information because in our minds we came up with all the extra details we'd ever want. Stephanie take any bit of extra information that she could come up with and crammed it into a book...stuff that we didn't necessarily even want to be told.
To sum it up in a thought, as my brother always says, every triliogy has a third movie. Even Star Wars had its horrible movie featuring Jar Jar Binks. This book was that third movie.